MAMEWorld Central >> EmuChat
View all threads Index   Flat Mode Flat  

Spelunker
In need of a new user name
Reged: 06/02/12
Posts: 38
Send PM
Re: The end? :(
10/16/13 06:01 PM


> 2) A large number of Bad Guys are making and selling commercial MAME ripoffs; they're
> in even big-name stores in Europe and Asia, there's the XXX-in-1 PCBs, there's the
> PS2 arcade discs Hamster made for Konami, there's Raiden Legacy, etc, etc. So it's
> not like the license is stopping anyone from doing unspeakable things.

I see this as no reason whatsoever to embark on such a large re-licence undertaking. 'Let's re-licence so as to make it easier on those ripping us off', you could have skipped this point imo.

> 3) The license has been a barrier to cooperation with other emulators. For those who
> haven't noticed, MAME has had it's clock thoroughly cleaned for fast and accurate
> emulation of modern and 3D systems by a parade of true open source emulators
> including SuperModel, PCSX2, Dolphin, DeSMuME, and nullDC. (Disclaimer: I'm involved
> with the SuperModel project, and I'm a fan of the rest of that list). Similarly, in
> many cases where other emulators have wanted to use MAME components, we've had to
> tell them "no", which doesn't exactly make them have warm feelings about the project.

This I can buy into, except I think this can be solved on a individual author to author or possible author(s) basis rather than a complete re-licencing of the project.

> On the MESS side, there's an even more formidable list of open source code which
> could be used to improve things if not for the license; our C64 audio emulation is
> terrible by any measure, and being able to drop in reSID like everyone else would be
> a large instant improvement.

This is where I have to admit I'm starting to side with you, I didn't think there were code Mame/Mess needed in this day from external and licence incompatible projects. If there are indeed still key components that Mame/Mess can't use due to licence incompability then I can certainly see reason for this re-licence proposal.

> Note also that nobody is selling any of those emulators in spite of their use of
> standard licenses which allow it; the GPL has proven legal teeth in both the US and
> EU, and it's hard to compete with free.

The GPL doesn't prevent commercial distribution, but yes a free version would be hard to compete with unless it drowns in a sea of commercial offerings with 'tweaks' to lure users in.

> If we end up
> in a license situation where we can offer official iOS and Android versions FOR FREE
> in the app stores, that would be amazing, but I'm not counting on it.

What would prevent you from doing this given the proposed licence changes? From what I can see with these changes anyone could release both free and commercial versions of Mame if it was licenced under BSD and/or LGPL which seems to be the proposed re-licence choices.

I'd like to state that I sure wouldn't mind seeing officially supported fully open versions of Mame/Mess on places like Steam, Google Play, iOS (do they allow emulators at all?).

> 5) Nobody's forcing anyone to do anything, nor will they be forced in the future.
> We're currently identifying the contributors to each of the source files and having
> them tag acceptable licenses. Nobody knows the final outcome yet, and MAME will
> continue to be distributed under the current terms.

So it will continue to be distributed under the current Mame licence, but also be dual licenced as either BSD or LGPL if they are to be included in the project as per the re-licence plans?

I'm glad to hear that my fears were by the sound of it unfounded, thanks for the info R.B







Entire thread
Subject Posted by Posted on
* The end? :( joey35car 10/15/13 11:58 PM
. * Haze go away or leave the rest of the team alone. Plan simple. Dullaron  11/01/13 01:25 PM
. * I call dibs on any code that says "Winners Dont Use Drugs" <nt> italieAdministrator  11/01/13 03:26 AM
. * Re: I call dibs on any code that says "Winners Dont Use Drugs" Vas Crabb  11/01/13 10:28 AM
. * Re: I call dibs on any code that says "Winners Dont Use Drugs" italieAdministrator  11/02/13 08:18 AM
. * Re: I call dibs on any code that says "Winners Dont Use Drugs" Vas Crabb  11/02/13 11:10 AM
. * Re: I call dibs on any code that says "Winners Dont Use Drugs" italieAdministrator  11/02/13 02:02 PM
. * Re: The end? :( SailorSat  10/22/13 12:44 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Chimp  10/17/13 02:54 PM
. * Similar to Linux kernel relicense discussion absence  10/17/13 01:13 PM
. * Re: Similar to Linux kernel relicense discussion R. Belmont  10/17/13 04:57 PM
. * Re: Similar to Linux kernel relicense discussion absence  10/18/13 06:09 PM
. * Re: Similar to Linux kernel relicense discussion Spelunker  10/17/13 06:11 PM
. * Re: Similar to Linux kernel relicense discussion Anonymous  10/19/13 07:27 PM
. * Re: Similar to Linux kernel relicense discussion Spelunker  10/20/13 04:27 PM
. * Re: Similar to Linux kernel relicense discussion Anonymous  10/20/13 07:48 PM
. * Re: Similar to Linux kernel relicense discussion Spelunker  10/20/13 09:26 PM
. * Re: Similar to Linux kernel relicense discussion Anonymous  10/22/13 07:31 AM
. * Regarding the illegal seller drama.... s_bastian  10/17/13 12:47 PM
. * Re: Regarding the illegal seller drama.... Anonymous  10/22/13 07:45 AM
. * Re: Regarding the illegal seller drama.... s_bastian  10/22/13 08:44 AM
. * Re: Regarding the illegal seller drama.... Anonymous  10/22/13 01:47 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Cyberzinho Punk  10/17/13 05:03 AM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/16/13 05:20 PM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/16/13 06:28 PM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/17/13 05:40 PM
. * Re: The end? :( B2K24  10/22/13 05:30 PM
. * Re: The end? :( bdam  10/17/13 07:06 PM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/17/13 09:27 PM
. * Re: The end? :( absence  10/18/13 06:24 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Anonymous  10/19/13 07:42 PM
. * Re: The end? :( SmitdoggAdministrator  10/17/13 01:00 AM
. * Museums StilettoAdministrator  10/17/13 06:22 AM
. * Re: Museums Anonymous  10/17/13 11:03 PM
. * Re: Museums SmitdoggAdministrator  10/17/13 06:33 AM
. * Re: Museums Matty_  10/17/13 07:18 AM
. * Re: Museums SmitdoggAdministrator  10/17/13 02:04 PM
. * Re: Museums gregf  10/17/13 09:29 PM
. * Why not put it to a vote? zambr  10/17/13 04:26 PM
. * Re: Why not put it to a vote? absence  10/18/13 06:05 PM
. * Re: Why not put it to a vote? SmitdoggAdministrator  10/17/13 04:58 PM
. * Re: Why not put it to a vote? Anonymous  10/22/13 07:52 AM
. * Re: Why not put it to a vote? SmitdoggAdministrator  10/22/13 03:01 PM
. * Re: Why not put it to a vote? Anonymous  10/23/13 03:21 AM
. * informative post gregf  10/16/13 06:18 PM
. * Re: informative post etabeta  10/16/13 06:20 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 06:01 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Kitsune Sniper  10/17/13 02:49 AM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/16/13 06:36 PM
. * Re: The end? :( RATMNL  10/16/13 08:10 PM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/16/13 08:34 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 07:28 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Anonymous  10/16/13 07:45 PM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/16/13 08:40 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Anonymous  10/16/13 10:24 PM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/17/13 05:03 PM
. * Re: The end? :( RATMNL  10/16/13 05:52 PM
. * Re: The end? :( RATMNL  10/16/13 12:51 PM
. * Re: The end? :( RATMNL  10/16/13 12:50 PM
. * Re: The end? :( SmitdoggAdministrator  10/16/13 02:57 PM
. * in response to academia and some museums with opinion of: gregf  10/16/13 06:39 PM
. * Re: in response to academia and some museums with opinion of: etabeta  10/16/13 07:39 PM
. * Re: in response to academia and some museums with opinion of: Anonymous  11/02/13 11:09 AM
. * Re: in response to academia and some museums with opinion of: etabeta  11/03/13 08:35 AM
. * Re: in response to academia and some museums with opinion of: SmitdoggAdministrator  10/17/13 12:43 AM
. * Re: The end? :( jumpmaniac81  10/16/13 05:18 PM
. * Re: The end? :( SmitdoggAdministrator  10/17/13 12:53 AM
. * separate issue gregf  10/16/13 06:51 PM
. * Re: separate issue SmitdoggAdministrator  10/17/13 12:50 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 04:25 PM
. * Re: The end? :( etabeta  10/16/13 04:57 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 05:35 PM
. * Re: The end? :( scarlet  10/16/13 10:25 AM
. * Re: The end? :( jonwil  10/16/13 05:00 AM
. * Re: The end? :( DJ_Infinity  10/16/13 04:03 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 02:32 AM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/16/13 05:39 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 06:03 PM
. * Will someone please explain? Antny  10/16/13 03:03 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? etabeta  10/16/13 08:10 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? Big Karnak  10/17/13 07:07 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? etabeta  10/17/13 07:35 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? Big Karnak  10/17/13 08:49 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? Lewis King  10/17/13 02:54 PM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? Sune  10/17/13 09:55 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? Firehawke  10/17/13 10:02 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? Sune  10/17/13 10:07 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? ranger_lennier  10/17/13 11:40 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? casm  10/16/13 03:12 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? DMala  10/16/13 05:38 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? Kitsune Sniper  10/16/13 07:06 AM
. * Re: Will someone please explain? Big Karnak  10/16/13 06:56 AM
. * Re: The end? :( casm  10/16/13 03:01 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 05:14 AM
. * Re: The end? :( casm  10/16/13 09:36 AM
. * Re: The end? :( SmitdoggAdministrator  10/16/13 03:47 PM
. * Re: The end? :( tamalmalamarrado  10/16/13 04:10 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 01:47 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Matty_  10/16/13 05:20 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Matty_  10/16/13 03:03 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Matty_  10/16/13 02:37 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 05:09 AM
. * Re: The end? :( R. Belmont  10/16/13 05:52 PM
. * Re: The end? :( Anonymous  10/22/13 07:57 AM
. * Re: The end? :( etabeta  10/22/13 11:51 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Anonymous  10/22/13 01:56 PM
. * Re: The end? :( etabeta  10/16/13 07:59 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Matty_  10/16/13 05:18 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Spelunker  10/16/13 05:33 AM
. * Re: The end? :( jumpmaniac81  10/16/13 01:33 AM
. * Re: The end? :( RetroRepair  10/16/13 02:04 AM
. * Haze just freaking out over changes that all. Dullaron  10/16/13 01:21 AM
. * Re: The end? :( gamez fan  10/16/13 01:02 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Lord Nightmare  10/16/13 02:47 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Lewis King  10/17/13 01:04 AM
. * Re: The end? :( casm  10/16/13 03:04 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Lord Nightmare  10/16/13 03:17 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Anonymous  10/16/13 11:28 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) goofy123  10/16/13 12:00 PM
. * you don't know what you're talking about... *nt* etabeta  10/16/13 02:11 PM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Anonymous  10/16/13 01:16 PM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Spelunker  10/16/13 01:53 PM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Anonymous  10/19/13 07:35 PM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Spelunker  10/20/13 04:37 PM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) etabeta  10/21/13 09:19 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Anonymous  10/22/13 08:00 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Big Karnak  10/21/13 10:14 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Matty_  10/21/13 10:42 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Big Karnak  10/22/13 05:22 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Mr. DoAdministrator  10/22/13 06:22 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Anonymous  10/22/13 08:05 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) etabeta  10/22/13 11:50 AM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Anonymous  10/22/13 01:50 PM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) SmitdoggAdministrator  10/22/13 06:18 PM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Lord Nightmare  10/22/13 09:11 PM
. * Re: The end? :( (edited) Lewis King  10/21/13 03:41 PM
. * Re: The end? :( casm  10/16/13 03:30 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Lord Nightmare  10/16/13 03:55 AM
. * Re: The end? :( MetalliC  10/16/13 04:37 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Lord Nightmare  10/16/13 05:16 AM
. * Re: The end? :( Matty_  10/16/13 04:50 AM
. * OSI-MAME... Ich glaub mir wird gleich schlecht! MASH  10/16/13 02:57 AM
. * Re: OSI-MAME... Ich glaub mir wird gleich schlecht! Lord Nightmare  10/16/13 03:00 AM
. * Re: OSI-MAME... Ich glaub mir wird gleich schlecht! DMala  10/16/13 04:59 AM
. * Re: OSI-MAME... Ich glaub mir wird gleich schlecht! R. Belmont  10/16/13 05:22 PM
. * Re: OSI-MAME... Ich glaub mir wird gleich schlecht! etabeta  10/16/13 07:43 AM

Extra information Permissions
Moderator:  redk9258, URherenow, Tafoid 
0 registered and 43 anonymous users are browsing this forum.
You cannot start new topics
You cannot reply to topics
HTML is enabled
UBBCode is enabled
Thread views: 12285