> > how the mame team approach the gdrom dumping?
> > trurip and redump seems to go in different routes
> Given that the softlist is composed of Redump, TOSEC and Internet gotten files, I
> would say they fit in what is best available.
Whoever decided to add TruRip/Dumpcast dumps as a priority over Redump dumps should be aware, that the former ones are sometimes bad dumps. http://dcemulation.org/dumpcast/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=1339 -- example.
And since they don't use an offset correction and cut certain gaps, some dumps are simply incomplete, more like old bin-cues compared to the proper offset-corrected dumps, if to compare with the CD world.